http://blogs.clariusconsulting.net/kzu

Daniel Cazzulino's Blog

Go Back to
kzu′s Latest post

Cloud-aware music done right: Spotify is the iTunes, Zune, Amazon Cloud Player and Google Music killer

Oh boy, how I’ve been waiting for something like Spotify!!! Just got an account setup (like 10’ ago) and I’m already blown away by it. Everything I’ve always wanted, truly.

To help you tell whether my evaluation is worth reading, these are the (music capable/usable) devices I own/owned and use/used actively:

  1. iPod Touch (first gen)
  2. iPad 1
  3. Zune Player
  4. T-Mobile G1
  5. Google Nexus One
  6. Galaxy Tab 7’’
  7. Galaxy Tab 10.1
  8. Windows 7 HTPC

And these are online music services I’ve used (either currently -soon to be dropped- or very recently). Note that they offer varying services and capabilities, so they cannot be compared easily, but they are all related to music, and I’m just noting the plus/minus I found for each:

  1. Grooveshark Anywhere: $9 per month
    + Offline caching (per playlist or per song)
    + Playlists that can be made offline entirely
    + Android support
    - iPhone/iPod not supported (blame Steve)
    - Sound quality very disparate
    - Duplicate songs, albums, kinda messy
  2. Zune Pass: $15 per month for unlimited downloads
    + 10 free songs to keep (plain mp3, no DRM)
    + Up to 5 devices simultaneously
    + Pretty extensive music catalog (far from everything, though)
    + Sleekest mobile and desktop app
    + Awesome music quality, even while streaming
    + Found good new bands from “Smart-DJ” mode (radio with a “seed” artist)
    - Microsoft-only
  3. iTunes – No streaming
    - Sync with a freakin’ cable, etc.
    - Pay per song/album
    - Epic #fail.
    (The first two alone discouraged me enough that I never bought a single song through it. Yeah, there’s a beta 10.4 of “iTunes in the Cloud” now, which still doesn’t do streaming. Too little, way too late)
  4. Amazon Cloud Player
    + Upload my existing songs
    + Nice Android app
    + Multiple (Android platform only currently Sad smile) devices supported
    + Amazon recommendation system behind your purchases
    - No radio mode
    - No subscription mode for unlimited streaming (have to buy songs/albums)
    - To sync my songs across devices, I have to upload to cloud and pay for storage
  5. Google Music: haven’t used it yet, but looks to be more or less like Amazon’s (-recommendations)
  6. Last.fm subscription: $3 per month
    + Multiple devices supported (even XBox!)
    - No offline support
    - No custom playlists that I could find

 

So I set out to try out for a month Spotify. Got a Premium account, and downloaded the desktop, Android and iPod clients. I hate iTunes with a passion, so I would have preferred a more creative desktop client than essentially a cleaned-up version of iTunes. I wish they copied Zune software instead which is truly gorgeous and (r?)evolutionary as a media player.

Now, here’s how you do sync in this age, Apple:

image

At no point, ever, you need to connect a cable between your computer and your device. Ever. Here I’m sync’ing for offline play on the laptop the most excelent Nightwish End of an Era CDs right off the cloud (I don’t own this album).

Here’s another view but now sync’ing to my Nexus One phone:

image

And now with ALL my current devices (except for the Zune) connected (couldn’t rename the Galaxy Tab 10.1 device, option appears greyed out Sad smile):

image

Truly amazing. Totally sold.

Needless to say, you can of course do everything you can do from the desktop client (except manage sync on other devices, AFAICS) from each mobile client (search, create playlists, cache for offline, etc.).

One thing I didn’t like is that you can only play on one device at a time. Starting on another pauses whichever other device is using the same username. I prefer the Zune’s approach of letting up to 5 simultaneous devices to be used. Imagine my wife is playing something on the HTPC for my kids and at the same time I’m working on my office. Can’t use my account on both. Means I have to pay more unnecessarily. Resorting to caching the music ahead of time and offlining one client or the other to avoid notifying Spotify and pause the other, is not going to work Sad smile.

 

As a general purpose music player for my local files, it also looks pretty decent, so although I’m sure I’ll miss the desktop Zune software, I think I’m ready to let it go.

Comments

1 Comment

  1. I tried to use on ipod touch 1g since google music is not compatible, this is not either as it needs ios 4 and that is not available for 1g ipod touch.